A Remnant Problem


I haven’t posted any physics problems for a while so here’s  a quickie involving dimensional analysis. You have to assume that the supernova remnant mentioned in the question is roughly spherical, like the one shown above (SNR 0500-67.5):

As usual, answers and comments through the box below please!

Click on the `continue reading’ thing if you would like to see my worked solution:

This is known as the Sedov solution for a spherical blast wave.


5 Responses to “A Remnant Problem”

  1. Probably made a mistake, but I get R propto E^0.2 p^-0.2 and t^0.4

  2. Anton Garrett Says:

    Typo in your equation for powers of mass! You typed \alpha + \gamma = 0 but you mean \alpha + \beta = 0.

  3. The assumption here seems to be that there’s no dependence on the initial mass of the star or mass of the ejecta…is that because it’s assumed that the mass of the star has a one-one correlation (approximately) with the energy of the explosion, and so there’s no need for a separate variable?

  4. I reached the same result in a rather quick and simple manner:
    assume that all the energy (E) of the explosion is turned into kinetic
    energy (KE) of the swept-up material.

    mass M = (4/3) pi R^3 rho

    avg velocity v = (R/t)

    KE = (1/2) M * v^2 ~ R^3 rho (R^2 / t^2) ~ R^5 rho t^(-2)


    E ~ R^5 rho t^(-2)

    Re-arrange to solve for R

    R ~ E^(1/5) rho^(-1/5) t^(2/5)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: